Laudon v. Roberts, [2009] O.J. No. 1824 (C.A.)

Date of Decision: May 07, 2009

Case Summary:
Our client appealed the trial judge decision to refuse to deduct an amount the plaintiff had received in damages from the co-defendant before entering judgment against him. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal holding that any amount the plaintiff received from a joint tortfeasor must be deducted from the assessment of damages and before judgment is entered against the second tortfeasor as failing to do so would allow the plaintiff to double recover. As the jury’s award was less than what the plaintiff had already received from the co-defendant, deducting the amount received reduced the judgment to zero and for the first time in Canada resulted in the dismissal of the action against a liable tortfeasor. Laudon v. Roberts has since been described on of the leading authorities on the issue of double recovery in the context of partial settlement agreements such as Mary Carter agreements.


Please click the pdf icon to view the complete case synopsis:

Contact Us


Tel: 416.368.4434
Fax: 416.368.7865

4711 Yonge Street
Suite 1110
Toronto, Ontario M2N 6K8


Tel: 613.567.8200
Fax: 613.567.8201

220 Laurier Avenue West
Suite 520
Ottawa, Ontario K1P 5Z9